RJ City on Building “Timeless” Toni Storm, Getting Washed Out by WWE, and His 70s Italian Horror Obsession

When you sit down with RJ City, you don’t so much conduct an interview as hang on and enjoy the ride. We caught up with AEW’s resident baby face himself aboard Chris Jericho’s Rock ’N’ Wrestling cruise, and over about twelve minutes he took us from Toronto to Toni Storm to 70s Italian horror to a genuinely impassioned defense of The Golden Girls. The full conversation is above. Here is how it went.

A State of Undress

“You caught me in sort of a state of undress,” he said. “I’m not usually seen like this, but you know what? I’m ready for my first day of high school, and I think it’s going to be great. I’m very excited to meet all the kids.”

He immediately questioned whether two interview hosts should even share a frame, calling it “two magnets that don’t go together.” When I reached for the old Gorilla Monsoon line about an irresistible force meeting an immovable object, RJ corrected me. “It’s an irresistible force and an irresistible force,” he said. “Whatever Hogan and Andre was, this is not going to be that.” He landed on a more fitting comparison: “I’m Iron Mike Sharpe, because, to get back to your original question, I’m from Toronto.”

From Toronto, By Way of Queens

RJ is Toronto born and raised, but the accent throws people, including me. The explanation is simple: “My mother’s from Queens.” He came up through Comedy Bar in Toronto rather than the Second City route. “There’s all these comedy things happening over there,” he said. “It’s rife with comedy.”

“There Was No Place in Wrestling for a Masculine, Blanche Devereaux”

Long before AEW existed, RJ was making his animated “Great Moments in Wrestling History” shorts and waiting for a business that had no room for him. “Hence my 20 years of a failed wrestling career,” he said. “There was zero place.” As he put it, there was “no place in wrestling for a masculine, blanched dandy.” Asked whether the problem was that the business simply wasn’t gay enough, RJ reframed it entirely. “It needs to be more self-aware of how homoerotic it is,” he said. “Someone tell JBL what is up.”

How Tony Khan Slid Into His DMs

RJ’s road to AEW ran, improbably, through a global pandemic. “I was doing dick in wrestling, as you can imagine, because there was no room for me,” he said. Then David Arquette “smuggled me onto a celebrity Zoom call” for WWE, which hired him for about a year and a half. “They’re like, ‘Well, let’s hire this guy. We need people who can talk at their computers,’” he recalled. “The world had to end for me to get some sort of employment.”

He squeezed a comedy special in between WrestleMania nights (“It was a miracle that I got any of it on”), and then, “like all things in WWE, random new people take over and they just wash the sand, and everything’s gone.” So he fired off a tweet pitching a bit about driving wrestlers to WrestleMania. “Tony Khan, ever with his finger on the pulse, slid into my DMs,” RJ said. “He knew all my stuff, which blew my mind, because who is reading my Seinfeld-doing-wrestling-material tweets? He was. He was the one guy.” The pitch Khan made back: come do exactly that, plus sit-down interviews.

RJ says he has operated without a single creative note ever since, “which is probably a blessing and a curse.” He still doesn’t have an official All Elite graphic, which is where that high-school gag pays off. “This is what I’m going to high school for,” he deadpanned. “He said if I get my degree, I can.”

The Birth of “Timeless” Toni Storm

No RJ City conversation stays away from Toni Storm for long. On how her “Timeless” character came together, he was blunt: “She fell into that. Her brain broke,” he said. “Something birthed out of her beyond, I think, whatever anyone could have anticipated. It just came out of nowhere.”

RJ, a self-described old-Hollywood buff, has been attached to the act, but he insists the credit belongs elsewhere. “It’s all credit to those girls, and to Luther, and to Tony Khan for birthing this sick, sick child,” he said, with a nod to the production team for “all the little effects they would add with the black and white.” Still, he kept circling back to Storm herself. “I knew her very little before that, but once Timeless started, that girl was gone.” The comparison he reached for was a Hall of Famer. “I can only liken it to Randy Savage, where you’re like, ‘Well, that’s just him,’” he said. “She just threw herself into that pond. She was really just the steam that ran that ship.”

Bringing Ben Mankiewicz and TCM to AEW

If there is one credit RJ will happily claim, it is a crossover nobody saw coming. “The one thing I will take credit for is getting Ben Mankiewicz and TCM involved in AEW,” he said. The TCM host’s Dynamite appearance had a ripple effect he loved. “I got so many texts from wrestlers who said, ‘My mother is finally watching Dynamite because Ben Mankiewicz is on.’” RJ has a grand theory about what that means. “They say Lou Albano and Cyndi Lauper,” he said, invoking the first rock-and-wrestling connection. “I say Ben Mankiewicz and Toni Storm led to the second wrestling boom.”

“Meal and a Match” and Catching “Biggs Heat”

That Mankiewicz coup got us reminiscing about WCW’s old Turner-synergy days, when the company folded wrestling into everything from Dinner and a Movie to WCW Nitro Grill. RJ and Renee Paquette tried to recapture that energy with a show called Meal and a Match. “It was us watching matches with wrestlers and eating,” he said. “We did, I think, five episodes.” Its demise, in his telling, had a very specific culprit: a simultaneous reboot of Dinner and a Movie starring Jason Biggs. “Who gives a…” RJ started, then caught himself with a grin. “I said it. You throw me off the air, I don’t care about standards and practices.” His conclusion: “He’s responsible for the second evolution of my career being stunted. I got Biggs heat.”

RJ’s Letterboxd Is a Giallo Vault

Ask RJ what he has been watching and you will not hear about the latest Marvel release. “I’ve been watching 70s Italian horror, the giallo genre,” he said. He did catch the recent Wicker Man remake, and docked it on Letterboxd over an expectation the trailer set up and the movie never paid off. “I took half a star off for that,” he said. For anyone looking to start, he pointed to the classics: “Four Flies on Grey Velvet is very good. Suspiria is very good.” His sell for the whole genre was pure RJ: “Those movies that don’t make any sense, but they look nice. It’s a wild time. It’s not going to come again.”

A Maude Man’s Guide to the Golden Girls

For the final question, I asked for his favorite Golden Girls episode, and RJ did not disappoint. “First of all, let me preface it by saying we’re going series for series. I’m a Maude man,” he announced, before praising that show’s famous abortion episode. “It certainly changed my stance,” he joked. “I reversed course. I made a few phone calls to my local politicians after that episode.”

On the Golden Girls proper, his picks were deep cuts. “I always love when Bea Arthur sings,” he said, citing her rendition of “What’ll I Do.” He also loves the episode where the girls lose a Miami tourism song contest, and he has a soft spot for the finale: “It’s just a strong story about all these women who bonded together, and then Dorothy leaves to marry Leslie Nielsen. That’s all it took.” He has no use for the spin-off The Golden Palace, and he signed off that section with a public-service announcement about Bea Arthur’s short-lived Fawlty Towers remake, Amanda’s. “It’s also very bad,” he said. “So all those women, keep them away from hotels.”

We sent RJ off with best wishes for his high school diploma and his future as an English major. The full interview is above, and keep an eye out for more from the cruise. We’re rooting for you right here at The Stunner.

Share This Story

Stunner Shorts

Watch all
Scroll to Top